Best Pizza in New Port Richey

Q: Where are you located?

We are located in New Port Richey, FL at 4209 Little Rd

Best Pizza Restaurant in New Port Richey Since 2006 – Sam’s New York Pizza– A Slice of Heaven Awaits!

Order online

Slice of Heaven

Featured

View menu

Savor a Classic Pepperoni Pizza!

A golden, crispy crust that crunches with every bite, paired perfectly with a savory tomato sauce that sings of tradition. But wait, it gets better! And then, behold the crown jewel: Generous layers of gooey, melted mozzarella cheese that pull apart in the most satisfying way, creating a cheesy masterpiece that defines comfort.

Honey BBQ Wings that Soar Above the Rest!

Our wings are meticulously seasoned and smothered in a luscious honey barbecue glaze, creating a symphony of flavors that dance on your palate. The perfect balance of sweet honey and smoky barbecue will have you savoring each and every bite.

Indulge in the Ultimate Meat Lover's Dream

Dive into a symphony of savory sensations with generous layers of premium meats that include succulent ground beef, sizzling Italian sausage, bacon, and pepperoni. Every bite is a celebration of carnivorous delight that promises to satisfy even the heartiest appetites.

A Sweet Serenade in Every Bite!

Crispy, golden shells embrace a luscious, velvety filling, creating a dessert that's both delightful and indulgent. Handcrafted with care, our cannolis are a testament to the same dedication to quality that defines our pizzas.

Order From Our Website

Order directly from our website to save money in fees, get faster service, earn free food via our rewards program, and support local business.

Order Online

Best NY-Style Pizza in New Port Richey Since 2006

Sam's New York Pizza, your go-to family pizza restaurant in New Port Richey, FL since 2006! We are proud to serve as an authentic Italian restaurant, crafting fresh, hand-tossed pizzas, savory pastas, and classic Italian favorites daily using the finest ingredients. Whether you want to join us in our cozy dining room, grab a quick lunch with our convenient pizza takeout, or relax at home with our fast and reliable pizza delivery. Experience the best local pizza and Italian comfort food around.

The food was delicious as always! I love the BBQ chicken wings. The BBQ sauce is amazing. I wish I could find out what kind it is. The pizza is always great. So are the meals. Will definitely keep ordering from them. Food: 5/5 | Service: 5/5 | Atmosphere: 5/5 Recommended dishes Garlic Rolls, Italian Stromboli, Stuffed Shells, Eggplant Parmesan, Chicken Parm Pizza, Special Pizza, Spaghetti with Meatballs, Wings, Pepperoni Pizza, Cheese Pizza

Carmella H.

Great prices, friendly staff, and amazing food. We tried the Cheese Pizza,Special Pizza, Meat Lovers Pizza, and the Baked Ziti with Meatballs. Everything was delicious, but the ziti was the most flavorful dish. This small local pizza place truly deserves the support. Highly recommend if you're looking for authentic New York-style pizza and Italian food in the Trinity area! I gotta say, Sam's New York Pizza is the best in Trinity for me so far.

Lawrence

It’s not easy to find a really great eggplant Parmesan sub, but I finally did, and it was at this restaurant. Also had a veggie pizza which was equally as awesome. Great crust and the toppings tasted fresh. Really delicious food and now my go to Italian restaurant. The owner is really nice for an added bonus as well.

Debbie C.

This was our first time here but certainly won’t be last! We love their Hawaiian/Pineapple and pepperoni pizza! We love the crust! This is how we like the crust, not too thick and not too thin. Best one we have! Thank you!

M.C. M.

Original planned on stopping at a different pizza place but they happen to be closed because of Labor Day so we found Sam’s and decided to give it a try and picked a few different things and it did not disappoint the raviolis were absolutely amazing the mozzarella had such a great cheese pull and they were so gooey 1000/10 definitely going back to try the rest of the pastas

racheal S.

For the past 10 years we've been bouncing back and forth between the two best pizza joints that we had found. Tonight we tried Sam's.. Without question the best we've found yet! Literally perfect! Looking forward to next time.

George W.

The pizza shop was an unexpected gem. I had the taste for some pizza, but I didn't want the chain options like a Dominos, Pizza Hut etc. I found Sam's and gave it a try. Clean, cozy intetior. Attentive staff and yummy food. This is my second time going in 10 days!

S.R.F.

Order "Pizza Delivery" or "Pizza Takeout"

Order online for delivery in New Port Richey, Trinity, Elfers, Seven Springs, and more. Or stop by 4209 Little Rd for dine-in and takeout to order the best pizza near you, along with Italian dishes, Subs, Wings, Calzone, Stromboli, Pasta, salad, and more!

Order Online